Sunday, March 30, 2008

I was wrong

I spelled Professor Michael Berenbaum's name wrong.
That may be why he has not responded to my request that he provide us with the name of "one person, with proof," who was killed in a gas chamber at Auschwitz. What else could it be?


Dave said...

Dear Mr Smth. It seems you attempts to elicit some form of resopnse from, well from anyone, have been in vain. It could be that you misspelled someone's name but you'll probably find it's due to the absolute nonsense and drivel contained on your web page. From my reckoning, many German's, soldiers and camp staff etc did in fact confess to the mass killing, by gas, of Jewish prisoners (not only Jews of course). In an interview on Swedish TV, former SS-Untersturmführer Dr. Hans Münch from Auschwith, admitted that 'special treatment' in the camp meant nothing other than gassing. Where the numbers were greater than just a few people, he states that gassing was the only viable means of disposal. Former SS-Unterscharführer Franz Suchomel, Treblinka, also spoke openly although apparently under anonimity, that each day, hundreds of Jews were taken to the corridors and chambers to be gassed. He reports seeing hundreds, all dead, so crammed into spaces that they died standing up.
I'm not going to bother following on with the evidence given, not by Jews or former inmates, but from German's themselves There is plenty of it. I'm really wondering what you suppose happened in these camps? Do you suppose they really weren't so bad, like so many Nazi's had stated? Bearing in mind Hitler himself stated that 'There must be no squeamish sentimentalism about it. The Jews have deserved the catastrophe that has now overtaken them. Their destruction will go hand in hand with the destruction of our enemies. We must hasten this process with cold ruthlessness.' and 'The procedure is a pretty barbaric one and not to be described here more definitely. Not much will remain of the Jews. On the whole it can be said that about 60 per cent of them will have to be liquidated whereas only 40 per cent can be used for forced labor.' Please Mr Smyth, how does this fit in with your view of these apparent 'Rumours'? And what did he mean 'liquidated'?


David Gantly.
Dublin. Ireland.

Bradley R. Smith said...

David Gantly:

Thanks for writing. Your post rehashes the orthodox story in every respect, which is only natural if you have not looked seriously at revisionist arguments. I am publishing it here only to inform others that this is exactly the kind of post (forgive me) that I am not interested in, as there is nothing new or informative in it for anyone who is familiar with the subject.

I have two questions that I am interested in receiving responses to here.

One: can you provide the name of one person, with proof, who was killed in a gas chamber at Auschwitz -- one out a million?

Two: do you believe it is reasonable, or unreasonable, to ask the question. If you argue that it is the latter -- why so?

Meanwhile, if you want to discuss these issues with guys who know something you can try the CODOH Forum at

Again, thanks for writing.


Dave said...

Please, keep asking away, I'd never deny anyone their right to question. One final question for you though, where would you expect to find a single name of someone who was sent to a gas chamber in, any of the camps? Are there documents reporting the deaths caused by shooting or by any means? I'm wondering why these would have been kept.

Bradley R. Smith said...

I don't know where the Germans would keep records of those they ostensibly murdered. We would want to know then how those who represent the Holocaust Industry can demonstrate the charges they make about the "unique monstrosity" of the Germans for having murdered a million or so individuals in gas chambers at Auschwitz.

Once we understand that they cannot provide the name of one person, with proof, who was murdered in a gas chamber at Auschwitz, we understand that their
claims about one million being murdered there are based on "assumption" as per Raul Hilberg. Meanwhile, if an American citizen is charged with killing one person, he is innocent until proven guilty of that specific crime.

Americans have demonstrated that they are intent on holding Germans to one standard of justice, one standard of morality, and ourselves to a different one.